Wednesday, 22 August 2012

Book Review: Sky Burial: An Epic Love Story of Tibet

Genre: History
Author: Xinran Xue
Rating 1 out of 5 Stars

First the synopsis.

Publishers weekly said:

"Inspired by a brief 1994 interview with an aged Chinese woman named Shu Wen, Beijing-born, London-based journalist Xinran (The Good Women of China) offers a delicately wrought account of Wen's 30-year search for her husband in Tibet, where he disappeared in 1958. After less than 100 days of marriage, Wen's husband, Kejun, a doctor in the People's Liberation Army, is posted to Tibet and two months later is reported killed. Stunned and disbelieving, 26-year-old Wen is determined to find Kejun herself; a doctor also, she gets herself posted to the isolated Tibetan area where Kejun had been. There, as one of the few women in the Chinese army, she endures much hardship and rescues a Tibetan noblewoman named Zhuoma. After being separated from her fellow soldiers in the wake of an ambush by Tibetan rebels, Wen, accompanied by Zhuoma, sets off on a trek through the harsh landscape. Years later, after going native with a tribe of yak herders, Wen learns the circumstances of Kejun's death and understands that her husband was caught in a fatal misunderstanding between two vastly different cultures. Woven through with fascinating details of Tibetan culture and Buddhism, Xinran's story portrays a poignant, beautiful attempt at reconciliation."
The New Yorker offered:

"In China these days, Tibet is all the rage: Beijing hipsters lounge in bars festooned with yak horns, pop divas sing ballads about Lhasa, and tourists mob the rooftop of the world. This novel, by a Beijing journalist now living in London, plays into the fantasy of the region as a Wild West populated by noble savages, with much to teach the cosmopolitan Chinese. Purporting to be a fictionalized account of a true story, it tells of a Chinese woman whose husband dies while on an Army expedition in Tibet, in 1958. She heads out west to learn the truth about his death, and winds up living with nomads for three decades, conveniently missing out on the Cultural Revolution. For American readers, the urge to mythologize the frontier will be familiar; but here there are no bad guys, only misunderstandings."
I say:

 BULLSHIT. The entire book screams bullshit. It is unbelievable. It is fantastical. It reeks of crap.
I cannot believe that the People's Army would allow Shu Wen to join the Army primarily to search for her husband. I do no believe the Chinese Army had so little information on his death. I refuse to accept the accounts of the Chinese Army suffering defeat after defeat at the hand of the Tibetans when known facts are otherwise. It strains credulity to think this woman could have wandered with the nomads in Tibet for 30 years and never found her way back to China.

This is a badly written book. It would be a badly written novel but it purports to be true.

As The New Yorker said, "In China these days Tibet is all the rage." Yes, and China seems to want to rewrite the history to show how terribly they suffered 'liberating' the Tibetans.

If any part of this book is based on actual fact, if any if it is more than the mad ravings of the author's fevered imagination, I will eat my hat.

(Originally posted to Multiply on August 15, 2008)

No comments:

Post a Comment